Nathalie Stutzmann (Foto: Jeff Fusco)
Interview with Nathalie Stutzmann

‘Of course I had expectations’

Nathalie Stutzmann made her Zurich debut in 2024. How does she look back on that? And why is she now returning with works by Richard Wagner?

Katharine Jackson

You made your debut as a conductor with us in November 2024. What memories do you have of that?

Standing in front of an orchestra for the first time is always a special moment. To be honest, it’s like driving a new car: you don’t know how it will react when you set off (laughs). You don’t yet know how you’ll be able to work with the orchestra – that is, what the communication between me and the musicians will be like. Of course, I had certain expectations of this fantastic ensemble, but with large orchestras, you simply can’t predict the chemistry. I can recall the rehearsals with the Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich and how we were quickly able to establish a common ground. I remember its sound very well; to me, it had something seductive, generous and grounded about it. I soon got the impression that the musicians were open to the kind of music-making that interests me – namely, focusing straight away on phrasing, organic rhythm, the search for distinctive timbres and the discovery of what lies behind the notes.

And the Tonhalle Zurich?

It’s a beautiful and inspiring concert hall with a rich sound – I prefer that to a dry one. You have to be very careful with the balance, especially with the woodwinds, to ensure that every important part can be heard clearly.

You’re returning to us with a composer who was also on the programme for your debut: Richard Wagner.

Richard Wagner has now become the centrepiece of my opera repertoire. I conducted "Tannhäuser" at the Bayreuth Festival in both 2023 and 2024. And at the moment I’m very busy preparing for my third time. To mark the festival’s 150th anniversary, I will be conducting a new production of "Rienzi" for the first time (Editor’s note: This interview was conducted in early summer, before the opening of the Bayreuth Festival). And returning to the Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich with Wagner was, above all, the wish of your management and the musicians. Added to this is the fact that symphony orchestras don’t play this repertoire very often and are therefore looking forward to it. That’s why we chose the prelude and the "Liebestod" from "Tristan und Isolde" and the overture to "Rienzi" for my return performance with you. And, of course, Brahms’s magnificent First Symphony, which is one of the works I love most.

A late symphonic debut

Johannes Brahms almost failed to put his First Symphony down on paper, for its composition was an existential struggle. Many of his contemporaries regarded him as Ludwig van Beethoven’s rightful successor, and being compared to this titan of music history weighed heavily on Brahms, both as a person and as an artist. He wrote the first sketches in 1862, but it was not until 1876 – when Brahms was 43 years old and Beethoven had been dead for 49 years – that his First Symphony was finally premiered in Karlsruhe. The famous conductor Hans von Bülow, a great admirer of Brahms, subsequently described it as ‘Beethoven’s Tenth’. This assessment irritated Brahms, but it quickly became legendary and shaped the perception of the work for decades. 150 years after its premiere, Brahms’s First can be heard in concert halls all over the world – as can his three other symphonies that followed. Johannes Brahms is buried in the Central Cemetery in Vienna, next to Ludwig van Beethoven.

Before your career as a conductor, you were a highly successful singer for many years and specialised in the contralto voice. To what extent do these two musical experiences influence one another?

There are very few conductors who were previously singers. To be honest, I hadn’t really analysed it that much when I made the switch. Singing was my main instrument, but I also grew up playing the piano, the cello and the bassoon. I was fortunate enough to experience music from very different perspectives. I see parallels between the pianist, the bassoonist and the conductor: when making music, you have to build a rhythmic architecture, construct a structure. As a bassoonist, you breathe in a similar way to a singer. As a cellist, you explore the magical possibilities of a string instrument through phrasing. And all these experiences have shaped me into the conductor I am today.

You’ve probably already guessed: you come from a family of musicians. Your parents were both professional singers. Did you have the opportunity, as a child or teenager, to try your hand at things beyond music?

Most of my parents’ colleagues had children who would have absolutely hated the idea of becoming musicians. Because they could see that it’s a crazy life, where you have to constantly study and practise new scores. I was the opposite, as it was always clear to me that I wanted to become a musician. For me, music has never been just a job; it’s my way of living life.

You seem to be at the peak of your artistic creativity. Would you say that you now possess precisely those qualities that make a conductor?

I wouldn’t say that talent comes with age. I think you either have it from birth or you don’t. At my age, I’m able to compare how I felt at 18 with how I feel today. Thanks to my life experience, I’m now a better musician than I used to be. Fortunately, I still feel just as athletic and energetic as I did when I was 30.

And what advice would you give to young conductors who are just starting out on their careers?

There’s nothing wrong with being a young conductor. You have to start somewhere. I think it’s important not just to be a conductor, but first and foremost to be a musician and an artist. You should lead a rich life, because that helps you to make artistic statements. Only those who have experienced intense emotional states can speak about love, passion or death. The music we interpret was composed by extraordinary people. And they had something to say because of their emotions and the circumstances they faced. And I’d also advise simply taking pleasure in learning.

You were the chair of the jury at the third edition of the international La Maestra conducting competition at the Philharmonie de Paris in 2024. In your closing speech, you spoke of a funny but also remarkable encounter.

I was once involved in a project for young children aged between four and seven. I explained a little about how conducting works, gave some practical examples and invited a few children up to me so they could have a go themselves. A little boy came on stage with his mum and said to me: ‘Every time we come to a concert, you’re the conductor. Can only girls become conductors, or can boys do it too?’ We all had a laugh, but it showed just how important visibility is. I assured him that gender doesn’t matter at all. This story speaks for itself: representation is important, and visibility is essential if we want children to understand that these opportunities are open to everyone.

You are Music Director of the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra and, from the 2026/27 season, will also be Artistic and Musical Director of the Orchestre Philharmonique de Monte-Carlo. You also conduct all over the world. Music, as you yourself have said, is a central part of your life. What else brings you joy?

If I didn’t have this great passion – or perhaps even obsession – for music, I wouldn’t cope so well with this demanding life and all the travelling. I have many other interests, but unfortunately hardly any time for them. I really enjoy going to the mountains, I love swimming in lakes or the sea, and I really enjoy snorkelling – the underwater world is a marvellous thing. And I take photographs with my Leica. Reading books, enjoying a film or having a good meal with my friends – that’s how I recharge my batteries. Quite simple things, really.

October 2026
Thu 22. Oct
19.30

Nathalie Stutzmann & Christina Nilsson

Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich, Nathalie Stutzmann Leitung, Christina Nilsson Sopran Wagner, Brahms
Wed 21. Oct
19.30

Nathalie Stutzmann & Christina Nilsson

Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich, Nathalie Stutzmann Leitung, Christina Nilsson Sopran Wagner, Brahms
published: 29.09.2026

Tags